Card Shops in Indianapolis, IN
Discover 6 local card shops in Indianapolis, IN. Find the perfect store for Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, and more.
Shop Locations in Indianapolis, IN
Loading map...
All Shops
Comic Carnival
📍7235 N Keystone Ave suite e
🏙️Indianapolis, IN 46240
Fan Cave
📍4805 Madison Ave
🏙️Indianapolis, IN 46227
Indy Card Exchange
📍7035 E 96th St ste p
🏙️Indianapolis, IN 46250
🕐Today: 10am-6pm
Mage's Comics and Games
📍7623 Shelby St
🏙️Indianapolis, IN 46227
🕐Today: 10:00 am-8:00 pm
The Card Depot
📍5345 Madison Ave
🏙️Indianapolis, IN
The Dugout
📍5707 W Morris St
🏙️Indianapolis, IN
Looking for shops in other areas?
Browse our full directory to find card shops across the country.
Browse All ShopsTrading Card Shops in Indianapolis, IN
Welcome to the most comprehensive directory of card shops in Indianapolis, IN. Whether you're a Pokemon TCG player, Magic: The Gathering enthusiast, Yu-Gi-Oh! duelist, or sports card collector, you'll find the perfect local game store here.
Our directory features 6 verified shops in Indianapolis, IN, offering everything from sealed product and booster boxes to singles, supplies, and play space for tournaments and casual games.
What You'll Find at Indianapolis Card Shops
- Pokemon cards - booster boxes, packs, singles, and graded cards
- Magic: The Gathering - sealed product, singles, and tournament play
- Yu-Gi-Oh! cards - structure decks, booster boxes, and singles
- Sports cards - football, basketball, baseball, and more
- Card sleeves, binders, deck boxes, and other supplies
- Grading services - PSA, BGS, SGC, and CGC submissions
- Tournament and event space for organized play
Each listing includes store hours, contact information, directions, and specialty focus areas to help you find exactly what you're looking for in Indianapolis, IN.